Why I Chose Supabase Over Other Online Databases
Implementing Supabase helped me build a secure, structured backend for my annual calendar app — without the chaos of NoSQL. Here’s why it clicked, and why I’d choose it again over Firebase.
MagnoliaCodes logo

Samantha Howell

Posted: 8 April 2025

When I started building my Annual Calendar App, I knew I needed a backend that matched the way I think — structured, relational, and secure. After trying Firebase in a previous project and feeling completely out of place, I decided to go with Supabase, and I haven’t looked back since.

Coming from a traditional IT and data background, and having managed a data analytics team, data design has always been step one for me. I naturally think in tables, relationships, joins, and constraints. Whenever I start a project, I begin by sketching out the schema — how the entities relate, what the rules are, and where the integrity needs to be preserved.

With Firebase, I constantly found myself asking:
“How does the data join?”
“What happens if I delete a parent?”
“How do I enforce integrity without foreign keys?”

Frankly, it made me uncomfortable — and a little scared.

What I Needed

For my Annual Calendar App, a personal project aimed at helping users plan and review their year visually, I had a few clear requirements:

  • A relational database with strong schema support

  • Open source, with a generous free tier

  • Built-in user authentication

  • Support for client-side development with Flutter

  • Optional serverless functions if I needed to scale logic later

Supabase checked all those boxes — and did it beautifully.

Why Supabase Clicked

Supabase gave me exactly what I needed, without fighting against how I think:

  • PostgreSQL at its core — so I could design my schema with familiar concepts like one-to-many relationships between users, calendars, events, and categories.
  • Built-in auth that just worked, no hacking required.
  • Row-Level Security (RLS) to keep each user’s data safe — an extra layer of control that made me feel confident in what I was building.
  • Super easy setup with clear documentation, and loads of community support, especially in the Flutter + Supabase space.
  • Client-side logic covered 95% of my needs, and I knew serverless Edge Functions were there if I wanted to grow.

I also appreciated how visible and intentional my data design felt. It wasn’t nested JSON blobs or sprawling documents. It was structured, queryable, and solid — just like a proper database should be.

 

Where Firebase Fell Short

If someone asked why I didn’t stick with Firebase, I’d say: “Because I value data integrity and I couldn’t get my head around a backend where foreign keys don’t exist.”

Firebase is powerful, especially for realtime apps, but I constantly felt like I was patching together structure where it didn’t exist by design.

 

Would I Recommend Supabase?

Absolutely — especially if:

  • You’re building something with structured data
  • You prefer SQL over NoSQL
  • You want auth, storage, and security built-in
  • You’re using Flutter, and want great documentation and community support

That said, if you’re building a realtime chat app or need a highly unstructured, rapidly evolving data model, Firebase might still be a better fit.

Key Takeaway

Implementing Supabase in my project gave me peace of mind. It felt natural. It matched the way I think, and let me focus on delivering value — not wrestling with the backend.

If you value structure, security, and developer joy, I highly recommend implementing Supabase in your next project.

keep reading…